e.l.f. 85025 Face Mist vs Heritage Store 9402508 Face Mist
These two face mists both target hydration and soothing, but they sit in very different spots on the shelf. The e.l.f. 85025 comes in at $8.00 for a 4-ounce bottle and has collected over 39,000 ratings, making it one of the most reviewed drugstore mists around. Heritage Store's 9402508 rosewater mist runs $14.29 and delivers a notably bigger 12-ounce bottle built around rose oil as its lead ingredient. Both are rated well, but Heritage Store edges ahead with a 4.7-star average versus e.l.f.'s 4.5 across a large sample of buyers. The right pick depends on whether you want rock-bottom price and a minimalist spray or a rose-forward, larger-volume option with a cleaner ingredient story.
Quick winner
Heritage Store 9402508 wins on rating, ingredient transparency, and value per ounce; e.l.f. 85025 wins on sticker price and sheer review volume.
Key differences, measured
- The e.l.f. 85025 is 44% cheaper ($8.00 vs $14.29).
- Amazon buyers rate the Heritage Store 9402508 0.2 stars higher across 60,500 combined reviews.
Side-by-side specs
| Spec | e.l.f. 85025 Face Mist | Heritage Store 9402508 Face Mist |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $8.00 | $14.29 |
| Rating | ||
| Form | Spray | Liquid |
| Skin type | All | All |
| Benefits | Hydrating, Soothing | Hydrating |
| Size | 4 Fluid Ounces | 12 Fluid Ounces |
| Free of | Paraben-Free | Paraben Free |
The two contenders
e.l.f. 85025 Face Mist
The e.l.f. 85025 is a lightweight spray mist designed for all skin types and all skin tones, priced at $8.00 for 4 fluid ounces. It lists hydrating and soothing as its two core benefits and is formulated without parabens. With more than 39,400 ratings and a 4.5-star average, it has proven staying power as an everyday refresher or makeup-setting mist. The bottle format is compact and handbag-friendly, though the 4-ounce size means you will refill it more often than a larger option.
Buy this if: Shoppers on a tight budget who want a fuss-free daily hydrating mist without spending more than $8. Anyone who prefers an unscented or lightly scented option, since the e.l.f. 85025 does not list a distinct scent. People who want a compact bottle that travels easily in a purse or gym bag.
Check price on AmazonHeritage Store 9402508 Face Mist
Heritage Store's 9402508 face mist centers on rose oil as its key ingredient and is listed as hydrating and soothing for all skin types. At $14.29 for 12 fluid ounces, the cost per ounce is lower than the e.l.f. option even though the up-front price is higher. It carries a 4.7-star rating across more than 21,100 reviews, is paraben free, cruelty free, and vegan, and is made in the United States. The rosewater scent is genuine rather than synthetic, which tends to matter to shoppers who are sensitive to added fragrance.
Buy this if: Anyone who wants a rose-oil mist with a clear key ingredient and a track record of nearly 21,000 buyers rating it 4.7 stars. Shoppers who go through mist quickly and want the better per-ounce value that the 12-ounce bottle provides at $14.29. Those who prioritize vegan and cruelty-free products and want something made in the United States.
Check price on AmazonFrequently asked questions
Which mist gives you more product for the money?
Heritage Store 9402508 comes out ahead on a per-ounce basis. At $14.29 for 12 fluid ounces you pay roughly $1.19 per ounce. The e.l.f. 85025 runs $8.00 for 4 fluid ounces, which works out to $2.00 per ounce. If you use a face mist daily, the Heritage Store bottle will last noticeably longer before you need to reorder.
Are either of these mists safe for sensitive skin?
Both products list all skin types as compatible. The Heritage Store 9402508 is also labeled paraben free, cruelty free, and vegan, and its key ingredient is rose oil, which is a traditional skin-soothing ingredient. The e.l.f. 85025 is paraben free as well. If you have known reactions to botanical extracts or rose-derived ingredients, the e.l.f. option with its simpler listed formula may be the lower-risk starting point, though you should review the full ingredient list for either product before use.
Can I use these mists over makeup?
Face mists are commonly used both before and after makeup application to support hydration throughout the day. The e.l.f. 85025 has a large base of makeup-oriented buyers given the brand's positioning, and its spray format is well suited for misting over a finished look. Heritage Store's rosewater mist is lighter in consistency and is similarly used for midday refresh. Neither product claims to be a dedicated setting spray, so results will vary depending on your makeup products and skin type.
How do the ratings compare given the difference in review counts?
Heritage Store 9402508 holds a 4.7-star average from more than 21,100 reviews, while e.l.f. 85025 holds a 4.5-star average from over 39,400 reviews. Both sample sizes are large enough to be meaningful. The half-star difference in Heritage Store's favor is consistent across a substantial number of buyers, suggesting its rosewater formula has earned a slightly higher satisfaction rate, though e.l.f.'s rating is still solidly positive.